That's a loaded question, isn't it?
For me, it really depends on the subject. If we are talking about reading, I'd lean towards....who needs them?
But, for math....well, I have mixed feelings about textbooks.
I spent the day today at our local textbook caravan for our math textbook adoption coming up this spring. Do you have to go to these?
Basically, teachers, instructional coaches and administrators are given a "sales pitch" by different textbook companies. Then, we go back to our home schools and try to "sell" the best textbook to our faculty. It's not a fool-proof plan, but one that I guess helps the process a bit. If you get too many teachers in one room trying to make the decision...well, I'm sure you know how that would turn out. Right?
I appreciated the chance to go today, but I am in information overload. My brain hurts. I also feel like some companies tried to "sell" me a little more than others (not naming names here). I'm not too sure how I feel about that, either. I think the product sells itself, don't you? I can see/read/analyze the textbook myself.
Anyway...I digress...I guess it's the information overload.
As many of you know already, I use "Math Workshop" in my classroom. One of the components is "Independent Practice" and for me, that time is used practicing the lesson that I taught my students in small group the previous day. Our math textbook has provided that "Independent Practice" because...well, it's free. It's not something I have to create, run off, staple together, laminate or cut out and oh, it's free. So, for me, the textbook is a resourceful tool. Does it completely fill all of my needs? No. Do I have to supplement? Sure. But, does it come in handy? Yes.
Here's my loaded question for you. I need your help. How do you feel about textbooks for math? Do you have a particular textbook (yes, we are naming names here) that you use that you LIKE? Dislike? I have a favorite as of right this minute, but I could be persuaded to feel a different way. {Not that it's my decision to make for my district, but I'd like to be able to share with my faculty at least what teachers like you think.}
Please, please, please leave me a comment sharing with me your favorites and why. If you'd like to share what you DON'T like, that's fine, too. If you'd prefer to email me (rather than leave it in my comments), I'd appreciate that, too. **Funinroom4b@gmail.com
Thank you, my dear, sweet readers for always being a great spring board for discussion. I've enjoyed my own personal/professional development that I've received through blogging this last year because of all of you. {Sure wish I could count it for my official PD!!}
So, let's get started...
Ready?
Comment....